California’s Subscription Laws Are Getting Stricter

California is updating its Automatic Renewal Law (ARL), bringing significant changes for subscription-based businesses starting July 1, 2025. At the same time, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has introduced amendments to its Negative Option Rule, with staggered effective dates beginning in 2025.

These updates are designed to make sure that businesses handle auto-renewals and subscription changes more transparently. For businesses, this means adapting processes to meet stricter requirements. Let’s break down what these changes mean and how to prepare.

California’s Automatic Renewal Law: What’s Changing?

California has always been serious about protecting consumers when it comes to subscription services, but this new update raises the bar. The focus is on making sure customers know exactly what they’re signing up for — and making it as easy to cancel as it is to start a subscription.

Free-To Paid Conversions.

If the your subscription model involves free trials that convert into paid subscriptions, you must now obtain affirmative consent for the paid terms before the customer is charged. This isn’t just a checkbox buried in your terms and conditions; it has to be obvious and specific. Think a clear statement like, “By checking this box, I agree to be charged $XX/month after my free trial ends.”

Express Affirmative Consent for Auto-Renewals.

The ARL has long required businesses to obtain affirmative consent before charging for automatic renewals, but the amended law raises the bar by requiring “express affirmative consent.” While the term “express” isn’t explicitly defined in the statute, this suggests a need for a higher standard of clarity and specificity. The safest bet is to make sure customers take a separate, clear action to agree to recurring charges — like checking a specific box or signing something that’s only about the renewal terms. The idea here is to remove any confusion and make sure the customer knows they’ll be charged again and again.

Detailed Pre-Billing and Post-Transaction Notices

Another key addition is around disclosures. Before confirming billing, businesses must present clear, upfront information about the subscription’s cost, renewal frequency, and cancellation method. While the law allows post-transaction acknowledgment emails, ambiguities in the new bill suggest businesses may need to include these disclosures both at checkout and after the transaction.

Simplified Online Cancellation.

Cancellation should be simpler, too. If someone signed up online, they need to be able to cancel online — no hoops, no phone calls unless they signed up that way. And while businesses can still offer retention deals or perks during the cancellation process, there has to be a straightforward “cancel now” button that’s easy to find.

Annual Renewal Reminders and Notification of Price Changes.

Get Cytowski & Partners’s stories in your inbox

Join Medium for free to get updates from this writer.

Remember me for faster sign in

For subscriptions with annual renewals, businesses must send consumers an annual reminder in the same medium that resulted in activation or in a medium in which the customer is accustomed to interacting with the business, detailing the product or service, the associated charges, and the cancellation procedure. Fee changes must also be communicated to consumers at least 7 to 30 days before they take effect, with clear instructions on how to cancel if the new terms are not acceptable.

Consent Verification Records.

Last, businesses are now required to retain verification of this consent for at least three years or one year after the contract is terminated, whichever is longer. The amendment does not specify the exact type of verification record that must be maintained.

What About the FTC’s Negative Option Rule?

At the federal level, the FTC’s updated Negative Option Rule aligns closely with the objectives of California’s ARL, though it is not as detailed in certain respects. The rule applies nationwide and addresses key areas, including enhancing transparency, securing clear consent, and ensuring the cancellation process is straightforward.

One thing the FTC really emphasizes is separating consent for negative options — like auto-renewals — from everything else. Customers need to say “yes” specifically to recurring charges, not just to the overall subscription. So, if your sign-up process is all rolled into one step, it’s time to rethink it.

The rule also stresses transparency. Businesses must clearly disclose critical details — such as pricing, renewal frequency, and cancellation methods — at the point where customers provide their consent. These disclosures should not be obscured within lengthy terms and conditions or overshadowed by unrelated information.

In addition, the rule requires that the cancellation process be as simple as the sign-up process. For example, customers who initiate subscriptions online must be able to cancel through an online mechanism without being required to make phone calls or complete unnecessary steps.

The rule also addresses price changes. Businesses are obligated to notify customers of any increases in fees well in advance, enabling consumers to make informed decisions about whether to continue with the service under the new terms.

Why This Matters and What You Can Do Now

Beyond any legal or monetary implications, these changes reflect a growing trend in consumer expectations: individuals increasingly seek greater transparency, reduced complexity, and a sense of control in their interactions with businesses.

For businesses that have yet to take action, this is an opportune moment to review subscription practices comprehensively. Walk through your sign-up and cancellation flows. Are they clear? Are there any spots where customers might feel misled or frustrated? Addressing any such issues now can prevent future compliance risks and customer complaints. Adding a dedicated step for auto-renewal consent, for example, could save you a lot of headaches later.

Make sure your disclosures are crystal clear, both at the time of sign-up and afterward. It is insufficient to merely include the necessary information — it must be presented in a way that is easily visible and readily understood by customers. And don’t forget to set up systems for sending out reminders and notifications about price changes or renewals.

Most importantly, consider the customer experience from their perspective. If a process feels frustrating or misleading to you, chances are costumers would feel the same way.

The Bottom Line

California’s ARL and the FTC’s Negative Option Rule are reshaping how subscriptions work. While the changes might feel overwhelming, they’re also an opportunity to build trust and loyalty with your customers. Start preparing now, and you’ll not only avoid compliance headaches — you’ll also stand out in a crowded market as a business that does things right.